October 7, 2008

Websites Worth Caring About

NOTE: This post is old, and is probably on different subject matter than my current writing. It is possible the information is outdated or my opinions have changed. -- Josh Klein, May 28, 2012

Attention grabbing headlines, link bait, squeeze pages, list building, social media and blahging.

These are the chew toys that have made me sad and tired and cynical.

I’m using (or butchering) the words of Merlin Mann, a writer whom I respect, who has been on a recent campaign to make blogs better [skip to 5:20 in].

It got me thinking. See, I read plenty of blogs about making and promoting websites. I bring the best stuff to my clients — and write about the subject — so it’s my job to be on top of what’s going on.

It can get depressing.

The atmosphere reminds me of the one leading up to the dot-com bust. The web seems like easy money, so entrepreneurial-minded people are trying to cash in their get-rich-quick cards.

For blogs in particular, everything is about driving traffic and readership, being perceived as a niche expert, and upselling leads on a product or service. Eyeball theory all over again. Bubble 2.0.

I’ve always been skeptical. My first post here was about how much harder it is to figure out “which to” than “how to” given the abundance of talking heads. I cautioned against The Bandwagon.

Too many people see newfangled tech as some kind of philosopher’s stone that turns everything it touches into gold. News flash: you’re not Midas, and making websites is not chrysopoeia. It would be an apt analogy to compare this misperception to a cause of the 2008 financial crisis:

There is an orgy of optimism surrounding sophisticated tools that allow for the wide distribution of shitty assets masquerading as something worthwhile.

In other words, it has become progressively harder to differentiate between what is worth caring about and what isn’t.

As my readership grew beyond friends and family — and I started checking my traffic stats daily — I started to slip into that irrational exuberance. The articles here didn’t always reflect my toeing of the dark side, but my marketing strategy did. I wanted more traffic, so I networked on Twitter, commented on widely read blogs, and built a readership in Stumbleupon.

None of it was satisfying and it sucked up a lot of time I could have spent on stuff that mattered. But the worst part is that it worked.

These tactics bring you traffic and money. But making a little bit of money has never been hard (just get a job).

Traffic is a drug. You start talking and someone listens, so you get louder and more people listen. I don’t know about you, but I don’t want to write a blog about the Top 10 ways Ducks Quack just because someone will read it.

When Technorati came out with their 2008 State of the Blogosphere, there was some controversy surrounding their claim that blogs with over 100,000 unique visitors per month were pulling in $75K+ in revenue. Fred Wilson, another guy I respect, revealed his blog with 150,000 unique visitors per month was pulling in only $30K (for charity).

Few are willing to admit that not all traffic is created equal.

The beauty of a blog is that it changes over time. I had a strategy when I started writing here, but not a real mission. That led to an execution that measured success in the wrong way. But now I think I’ve got it.

I’m passionate about using the internet to redefine our world. That’s why I’m here.

This is a blog about creating websites worth caring about — websites that matter to people. Not coincidentally, these are the websites that make money.

This all translates to a few tangible changes that will take place here over the next few months. I’ll bring up the changes as they occur. The agenda is not entirely clear, which is the point. Let’s see where this goes. Thanks Merlin.

---
  • http://www.brandthunder.com Kevin Dwinnell

    Interesting post. I spent many years in the internet space, but in a corporate environment. I was able to play with and keep aware of the technology and changing landscape, but wasn’t necessarily forced to use all the technology – just have an opinion on it.

    Now, I’m in a role that is much more dependent on using the current technology (meaning blogs, social networks, et al) and I’ve struggled with it. I read that with blogs, I should “join the conversation” but having spent time with CompuServe forums (back in the day) blogs seem like a bunch of people talking and not so much dialogue.

    I’m moving off that perception. It’s interesting. It’s different. It’s not what I expect, and ultimately, like you am looking forward to seeing where this goes.

  • http://therottenlittlegirls.com Dollface

    Interesting article. My blog is still pretty new (only a few months old) but I've been seeing a steady upwards trend in terms of page hits & reader comments. I hope to eventually grow the blog exponentially in that sense. However I am not interested in the money aspect at all. I want to increase readership so that my ideas can reach more people and I can interact with others. Even if I could make good money with my blog in the future, I really care about creating useful, good content for the enjoyment of others.

    When you said, “I’m passionate about using the internet to redefine our world. That’s why I’m here,” that really spoke to me. I feel the same way.

  • http://therottenlittlegirls.com Dollface

    Interesting article. My blog is still pretty new (only a few months old) but I've been seeing a steady upwards trend in terms of page hits & reader comments. I hope to eventually grow the blog exponentially in that sense. However I am not interested in the money aspect at all. I want to increase readership so that my ideas can reach more people and I can interact with others. Even if I could make good money with my blog in the future, I really care about creating useful, good content for the enjoyment of others.

    When you said, “I’m passionate about using the internet to redefine our world. That’s why I’m here,” that really spoke to me. I feel the same way.

    • http://www.joshklein.net joshklein

      Awesome. I think a blog, barring a direct commercial reason for existence, is an investment in yourself. I'm glad others feel the same way.

  • http://www.learnaboutpoverty.org NigePresto

    Hi Josh,
    An excellent post that seems to really capture the vibe that I am getting from a few different people at the moment – online and offline.
    When I read the post title, I was initially intrigued because I work for an aid organisation who is constantly grappling with creating and fostering ongoing relationships with people online, rather than just the 'big bang' of publicity or traffic.
    Keep up the good work…

  • http://www.learnaboutpoverty.org NigePresto

    Hi Josh,
    An excellent post that seems to really capture the vibe that I am getting from a few different people at the moment – online and offline.
    When I read the post title, I was initially intrigued because I work for an aid organisation who is constantly grappling with creating and fostering ongoing relationships with people online, rather than just the 'big bang' of publicity or traffic.
    Keep up the good work…

    • http://www.joshklein.net joshklein

      Thanks Nige. I'd love to hear more about the aid organization. There is a website I'm working on for a non-profit in the education and green sectors, and we're always curious about what other non-profs have found most successful.

  • http://besttimetools.com Michael Wilkes

    Your sentiments here seem to jive with much of the other input I have received on blogging… or having a web property up at all. The concept of being useful, contributing something of value, is what eventually brings a financial gain. Solomon said, “Do you see a man skilled in his work? He will stand before kings…” I think that is a key tenet of what we do on the web as well. Master a subject. Carve out a space. Be about something. And put yourself and your passion into the process.

  • http://besttimetools.com Michael Wilkes

    Your sentiments here seem to jive with much of the other input I have received on blogging… or having a web property up at all. The concept of being useful, contributing something of value, is what eventually brings a financial gain. Solomon said, “Do you see a man skilled in his work? He will stand before kings…” I think that is a key tenet of what we do on the web as well. Master a subject. Carve out a space. Be about something. And put yourself and your passion into the process.

    • http://www.joshklein.net joshklein

      Smartly put, Michael. As you clearly believe, given your quote of Solomon, this almost has nothing to do with the web. This is a life lesson, a philosophy on work and success. What will our legacy be? You can “fake” pan flash success, but is their any other path to greatness but greatness?

  • http://intellectualcapitalreport.com Augie

    So, I think there are a couple of different kinds of blogs out there: general (usually pop culture/news) blogs and niche blogs.

    In my own experience, I have found blogs that surround a specific subjects (SEO, Marketing, Technology, and in my case Real Estate) to be more interesting and more worth while. While I think there is a place for sites that blog about 100,000 topics, my feeling is that's what the aggregators are for.

    It's important to get your word out there by whatever means possible, but if your content is bad, you may get lots of traffic, but your bounce rate will be through the roof.

    I have no proof of this, but I would anticipate that high bounce rate equals low conversion rate. Is there anyone with several web sites that may be able to attest to this?

  • http://intellectualcapitalreport.com Augie

    So, I think there are a couple of different kinds of blogs out there: general (usually pop culture/news) blogs and niche blogs.

    In my own experience, I have found blogs that surround a specific subjects (SEO, Marketing, Technology, and in my case Real Estate) to be more interesting and more worth while. While I think there is a place for sites that blog about 100,000 topics, my feeling is that's what the aggregators are for.

    It's important to get your word out there by whatever means possible, but if your content is bad, you may get lots of traffic, but your bounce rate will be through the roof.

    I have no proof of this, but I would anticipate that high bounce rate equals low conversion rate. Is there anyone with several web sites that may be able to attest to this?

    • http://www.joshklein.net joshklein

      Thanks for the comment Augie. I think you're right, especially in that people focus too closely on “traffic” without a coherent strategy that answers the big question: “What's so great about traffic, anyway?”

  • http://www.joshklein.net joshklein

    Thanks for the comment Augie. I think you're right, especially in that people focus too closely on “traffic” without a coherent strategy that answers the big question: “What's so great about traffic, anyway?”

  • http://www.joshklein.net joshklein

    Smartly put, Michael. As you clearly believe, given your quote of Solomon, this almost has nothing to do with the web. This is a life lesson, a philosophy on work and success. What will our legacy be? You can “fake” pan flash success, but is their any other path to greatness but greatness?

  • http://www.joshklein.net joshklein

    Thanks Nige. I'd love to hear more about the aid organization. There is a website I'm working on for a non-profit in the education and green sectors, and we're always curious about what other non-profs have found most successful.

  • http://www.joshklein.net joshklein

    Awesome. I think a blog, barring a direct commercial reason for existence, is an investment in yourself. I'm glad others feel the same way.

  • http://paradox-marketing.blogspot.com/ Justin Hamlin

    This was great information and the lead -in fom the other page was great too. I commented back on my blog.

  • http://paradox-marketing.blogspot.com/ Justin Hamlin

    This was great information and the lead -in fom the other page was great too. I commented back on my blog.