June 1, 2011

Google +1: A response to Facebook Like-button, minus the usefulness

NOTE: This post is old, and is probably on different subject matter than my current writing. It is possible the information is outdated or my opinions have changed. -- Josh Klein, May 28, 2012

Google has released their +1 button, an answer to the ubiquitous Facebook “Like” button.

As a publisher/advertiser, the attractiveness of Facebook’s Like-button is in the way it gets your communication into a user’s social feed. If enough people in my Facebook social circle like a page, it will probably show up in my news feed, and I may be tempted to check out what all the fuss is about. This is the core mechanism that makes something go viral on the social network. Google’s +1 button aims to do the same, but there’s a hitch.

Who exactly is my “Google friend”?

Facebook still gets a lot of flak for mixing up our various “friend” contexts; do I really want to have one place where I connect with family, friends, co-workers, or strangers I met at a party? But over time, individuals come to some sort of equilibrium about how they use Facebook. Google can’t say the same; at least, not yet.

The now-defunct Google Wave worked by pulling in all of our Gmail contacts, but as many of us have over a half decade of email history, this isn’t an accurate reflection of people whose opinions we trust. Herein lies the unanswered element of Google’s social platform – what is the context of my “friend” relationships?

And the elephant in the room … will the search algorithm change to reflect my individual social/usage history?

---
  • http://WebsiteURL Joe

    The elephant in the room really is huge. Why would google be interested in collecting all the data on the amount of +1′s if they were not going to use all of this real human data to influence the rankings. Google goal with their rankings is to show the best websites to searchers – and if these searchers are flat out telling Google what sites they like the best, it only seems natural that Google will rank those sites higher.