September 9, 2008

Facebook is not a social network. No, really.

NOTE: This post is old, and is probably on different subject matter than my current writing. It is possible the information is outdated or my opinions have changed. -- Josh Klein, May 28, 2012

Many people are salivating like rabid hounds to incorporate social networks in their web strategies. This isn’t news. It seems like the magic bullet: “we’ll all be rich if we can just figure out how to go viral in the social networks!”

I want to offer a word of caution, and 5 rules to do it right.

Social networks have existed since the origins of human communication. I speak with some people directly, and others through their connections, so I have a network of social ties.

Logo for Facebook

In ancient times (the 1990′s), we maintained our social networks through silly things like emails, phone calls, and parties. Then websites started to pop up that allowed us to stay in touch with our friends… a lot more of them. We decided to call them social networks.

This misnomer has plagued us since.

Facebook is not a social network. It’s a platform for people to host a web version of their social network. Calling Facebook a social network suggests a singular, regimented set of individual connections, which is simply not the case.

In other words, Facebook plays host to millions of individuals’ personal networks.

This may seem like a useless semantic argument from a web insider, but this matters.

So-called “social networks” are not magical. The same strategies for success apply there as with any kind of word-of-mouth between customers and their close network of friends.

Which is to say, most people’s “social network strategy” is akin to relying on blind luck that people will love them enough to rave to friends.

Naturally, this is only half the story.

There are important measures to make sure you facilitate the word-of-mouth when it happens, but the key insight is that you’re more likely to go overboard than you are to take advantage of the low-hanging fruit.

And don’t forget cost. This ain’t free!

Don’t be lured by the illusion that free-of-charge means free-of-cost. Those who succeed spend tons of time working within the space, or spend plenty of money making their organization worthy of word-of-mouth.

Here are the 5 social networking rules to follow:

1) Get over the novelty

People talking to their friends through this new medium has vast sociological implications. For most businesses, that sociological change is completely irrelevant.

At a fundamental level, social networks are just another way people communicate directly with friends.

2) Social networks aren’t right for everyone

People talk about businesses worth talking about. Duh. Unless you’re worthy of word-of-mouth, flooding a new channel is a waste of time.

Not every successful business is a word-of-mouth business. Don’t feel obligated to overwhelm your existing strategy with a new direction.

That being said… we can all agree that word-of-mouth businesses are the best businesses out there (another duh). Maybe you should be one?

But don’t confuse your social networking strategy with your business strategy. Deciding to be a business worthy of word-of-mouth is a much larger decision, and requires a whole different mindset.

I happily encourage you to be a business worth caring about.

3) Be present, but get out of the way

The first step for success is just to be there. Be listening to what people are saying about you and make it easy for people to spread the message by giving them resources like stories and pictures.

But mostly, get the hell out of the way. If people want to talk about you, they will.

Talk to your passionate fans, give them what they want, and ask them to tell people. The rest is out of your control.

People build their social networks, it’s theirs, so get your grubby hands off it. Interrupting people who are busy ignoring you is a surefire way to lose them.

Please understand that 15-25 year old Facebook users are largely anti-establishment, anti-consumerism, anti-corporation, and anti-authority. Proceed with caution and extreme honesty.

4) If you must advertise, be highly relevant

There is not overwhelming evidence that inappropriately targeted Facebooks ads are any more effective than setting your money on fire and stomping on it like a rhinocerous. Admittedly, I haven’t yet seen any field research on that. If you’d like to fund some, contact me.

Strictly targeting by demographic is useless because Facebook users aren’t in the buying state, discovery state, or any other mental state where they would give a hoot about you.

Facebook users are in the socializing state.

If you have something relevant based on their socializing, they’ll be ready to hear what you have to say (and the demographic targeting will be absurdly effective).

5) Be a human being

Being human is a rule of business in general (people buy from people), but especially true in the faceless anonymity of the web.

If you’re a giant faceless company, you better pick someone to be your point person on social networks. I’ve heard titles like Community Manager and Outreach Strategist.

If you’re a small company CEO or individual, for goodness sake, don’t pretend you’re not!

More than ever, being small and personal is a distinct advantage in business. Overwhelmed with modern economic life, attention scarcity, and constant subjugation to big business consumerism … we’re refreshed by the human approach.

Sorry to go off on one of my sociology rants, but the 21st century will be about personal, local, and organic (in all of it’s meanings). Get started now.

Here’s the thing

I think there is nothing more important than being a business worth caring about. For all sorts of philosophical reasons, I think life is too short and precious to separate business success from your personal satisfaction and connection with society.

So-called social networking websites make it more PROFITABLE to be this kind of business because when people tell their friends, the message spreads farther and faster.

It is more economically feasible to transform your business into a word-of-mouth business now than ever before.

And that is the reason Facebook is still worth caring about.

So says every business professional worth listening to.

---
  • http://twitter.com/covati Adam Covati

    While I think you have some great points here, I’m still not sure I see the value of your argument about facebook not being a social network.

    Sure, it’s not a network, it’s a tool for maintaining and expanding them through the internet. But most net based tools are metaphors, at best, for what you do in the real world. They are approximations of concepts that often have no physical analog in the real world.

    That being said, I’m not sure most people get WOM either, but I guess explicitly drawing that connection is quite valuable to people who still see facebook, twitter, etc. as some sort of mythical marketing machine.

    ok – end rant.

    I totally agree with 4 and 5, two of the biggest things that many companies are missing the boat on.

    /Adam

  • http://www.joshklein.net Josh Klein

    I worried about that Adam … to someone familiar with these tools it seems intuitive. But through my experience working with some clients not as well versed in the space, who rely on our expertise, I’m troubled by the awe and mystery with which they request recommendations for approaching social networks.

    And you’re so right that WOM is as much a mystery as social networks. Maybe that should be another topic in it’s own right, though there are much better minds than mine covering it at length (Andy Sernovitz and Seth Godin come to mind).

    Glad we agree on #4 and #5. Have any rules of your own?

  • http://twitter.com/closetgeekshow Brent Morris

    The lesson that a social network is not a website and is rather a collection of the social graphs (that is, the connections and relationships between people) of its users is probably the most important lesson people need to grasp from this.

    Once you realize that something becomes viral by being interesting enough to be passed between individuals, is when you realize that you’re speaking to real people and your messages need to respect that in order to be successful.

  • http://www.joshklein.net Josh Klein

    @Brent – Well said. The respect can be so hard. Businesses are used to treating people like consumers.

    Consumers have only 2 possibilities: consume, don’t consume. Anything you can do to make the consumption happen is fair game.

    But the twist is… no one is a consumer. We share, too … whether we tell a friend or post it on Facebook. And some produce too, in terms of extending a business’s impact even further.

    When you take the “anything is fair game” consumer approach to these people, you screw it all up.

    And you have it nailed on the head by naming it “respect”.

  • http://www.twitter.com/niphal Andrew Beeston

    A couple of things – I have been sitting here wondering what to reply with as I have a few ideas in my head that haven’t come together yet. I might just put them down in point form.

    – I think of Facebook as more of an ‘owned social network’ – in that your traffic and interactions with people essentially are owned and gated by Facebook. They facilitate you entering into other people’s networks and creating a larger one if possible.

    – I would go further to add to the ‘people buy from people’ and say ‘people buy from people they like’. People like people with similar interests, that’s why music sharing works so well. Take for instance the band All Mankind(.net) You’ve probably never heard of them before, they’re a rising Aussie band. But if I said their producer worked on artists like Sting & Elton John, they sound like U2, Crowded House and have influences like Pearl Jam – then you would more likely assess them on your similar/dissimilar interests (StumbleUpon connects people like this). That’s the good thing about these so called social networks, they provide the framework for us to assess each other and connect more easily and ‘like’ each other before we like each other.

    – Not sure if I read it already or not but as with any business it takes time to build and get a social network of your own. That’s a part of being human and I think it’s a really good thing. Get over the novelty indeed! To really work it well – I think longevity and constant activity will really work a lot better in the long run.